Dalit Panther: The Truth Underlined
by Arjun Dangle
Orient BlackSwan
Pages: xxv + 330; Price: Rs 999
The Dalit Panther took Maharashtra by storm in the 1970s. But within years, the movement first waned and then imploded, riven as it was by egoistic leaders. Although it has ceased to exist as a central organised force, the militant Dalit consciousness it spawned has grown from strength to strength across the country.
Despite many books and analysis, the Dalit Panther’s birth in 1972 and a most unexpected dissolution just five years later remain largely shrouded in mystery amid contrasting claims. Now, one man who was at the heart of it all has come out with a penetrating study of the short-lived outfit, a few of whose early stalwarts remain active in politics even today.
Arjun Dangle’s thorough study is a refreshing appraisal because it presents a critical examination of colleagues not always laudatory. Some accounts have a tinge of bias but they also seem to be realistic reflections of the inner tensions and contradictions born out of ideological differences and rivalry for power among those who were once close friends.
No movement comes into being all of a sudden, as if my magic. There is invariably a chain of events behind its inception embedded in the social, cultural and political context of its time. This was true for Dalit Panther too, which took its name from the Black Panther in the United States and whose birth was laid by centuries of horrific oppression the Dalit community had suffered in caste-driven Indian society.
The Dalit literary movement – a rebellion against the mainstream establishment in Marathi literature — was closely linked to the formation and growth of Dalit Panther (again like in the US). Yes, there was a Republican Party of India (RPI), representing the interests of the Dalit community, but it had no separate youth wing. Also, its factional leaders were reluctant to allow younger members to assume leadership positions. Everything combined to give birth to the Dalit Panther in July 1972.
The late 1960s and early 1970s were a turbulent period globally, India included. Pakistan had split up after a liberation struggle against military rule in its eastern wing. Wars were raging in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia. The Naxalite revolt shook India before it was brutally put down. Like in Paris, student protests gathered steam in Gujarat and Bihar. In Maharashtra, the Shiv Sena was coming up in a big way. The Dalits had plenty to ponder over. An official Indian committee said in 1971 that upper-caste landlords had killed 1,117 Dalits within a span of one-and-a-half years. It was a sickening situation.
The real strings of the Dalit Panther movement were in the hands of two men: Raja Dhale and Namdev Desai. When the group took off, it really took off – akin to a speeding panther. Raja quickly became popular among Dalit and Buddhist youths due to his radical speeches and vitriolic comments against Hindu gods and goddesses – like the Dravidian rationalists in Tamil Nadu.
Raja caused a storm when he dared to try burning a copy of the Gita, among the holiest of Hindu books, in March 1973. Days later, Namdev hurled a shoe at the Shankaracharya of Puri. What may have been blasphemous to many Hindus helped the Panther to expand its influence rapidly across the length and breadth of Maharashtra, including in rural areas. Dalit youths beamed.
Another factor which helped the Panther to grow was its courage to take on the Shiv Sena. Panther leaders treated upper caste government and police officials with disdain. If they went to a police station, they would ask the policemen to fetch them water saying: “You have denied us water for the last two and a half thousand years.”
Author Dangle, born into a poor family like so many Dalits, was one of the founder members of the Dalit Panther, which was born out of the struggle to transform a deeply flawed social structure. Unlike many parties which evolve over time, the Dalit Panther grew so fast that it laid the seeds for its internal destruction sooner than most people expected.
Among other factors, tensions between the socialists (who were closer to Raja) and communists (who had warm ties with Namdev) led to an internal rift which never healed. The terrible riots in Worli in Maharashtra in 1974 involving the Panther and Shiv Sena which led to half-a-dozen deaths and widespread property destruction played a key role in splitting the Panther.
The Congress, masters in politics, took advantages of the differences within the Panther to play one group against the other with deadly results. Very soon, rival leaders were accusing one another of taking bribes from the Congress-led government in Maharashtra. The unending and uncouth attacks on Hinduism alienated many non-Buddhists from the Panther.
“For any organisation to grow, three factors are crucial: financial resources, a committed cadre of activists and a clear ideological direction,” says Dangle in his engrossing book. “The Panther lacked all three. Ironically, the tremendous public support it initially received also contributed to the split as it inflated the egos of both Raja and Namdev.” Raja expelled Namdev from the Panther in 1975. The latter, however, continued to use the Panther name. Irritated, Raja unilaterally dissolved the Panther in February 1977, abruptly ending one of independent India’s most revolutionary political experiments.
The tragedy is that Panther leaders mocked at the RPI for their failure to function in a united manner. But the same disease gripped the Panther. Raja, says Dangle, lost his militant edge once the Congress lost power nationally in 1977 as some of his socialist friends were now a part of the new Janata Party government in New Delhi.
Dangle’s analysis makes it clear that some of those who led the Dalit Panther did not know how to handle their sudden popularity. They also did not have the leadership qualities to take everyone along. Like novices, they bickered over petty differences and refused to make compromises for the sake of the larger community’s interests.
Dangle is clear that Ambedkarites need to introspect where they are in parliamentary politics today, and identify the Dalits’ true friends and foes for the road ahead. This is a must to revive the Dalit movement if not the Panther. For a start, it would be important to make the Republican Party of India united and powerful.
But who will bell the cat for that? Dangle doesn’t provide the answer.
Mainstream Weekly