Home > 2026 > Judicial dismantling of Forest Rights Act | C. R. Bijoy

Mainstream, Vol 64 No 27, November 16, 2026

Judicial dismantling of Forest Rights Act | C. R. Bijoy

Monday 16 November 2026

The Supreme Court (SC) in A. John Kennedy & Others v. State of Tamil Nadu & Others (Civil Appeal Nos. 6395–6397 of 2025) on 6th November 2026, finally acknowledged that there are right holders under the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 20061 (FRA) amongst those that it had earlier ordered to be evicted immediately for forest encroachment in the Agasthyamalai landscape in Tamil Nadu. In effect, it tacitly acknowledged that FRA is indeed the legal basis of determining right holders on forest land, and therefore identifying forest land under encroachment and the encroachers.

Even while confirming and castigating the Tamil Nadu Government for being ‘primarily responsible for the delay in the process of receiving, identifying and adjudicating the claims under the FRA, 2006’, the Court, ‘by way of indulgence’, acceded to the Government’s belated request to initiate and complete FRA implementation in the Meghamalai region of Theni District, the most affected by the Court’s eviction order. A strict time line was dictated.

Within 30 days of the Court’s order the activation of the Gram Sabhas for FRA implementation has to be completed. Within another five months the three-tiered mechanism under the FRA has to complete the ‘statutory culmination of the claims process’. That means the completion of the submission of forest rights claims followed by their verification, determination of rights and decision on them by the Gram Sabha, and scrutiny of the claims by the six-member Sub-Divisional and the District level committees with members representing the Revenue, Tribal Welfare and Forest Departments along with three elected panchayat members nominated by the District Panchayat.

But then the sub-divisional and district level committees are defunct in most parts of the State (28 district outs of 38) as the term of the panchayats had expired way back in December 2024 itself. Nor did the government bother to extend the period of the erstwhile committees till the next election to ensure FRA implementation. It is now speculated that the panchayat elections may take place early next year only, most likely by mid-year, after the Tamil Nadu State Election Commission completes undertaking the delimitation of wards ahead of the elections. Until these committees are reconstituted, the Gram Sabha resolutions on the claims cannot be scrutinized and finalized.

The court constituted a committee headed by Justice B. R. Gavai, former Chief Justice of India, assisted by an officer of the Central Empowered Committee (CEC) and the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests & Head of Forest Force, State of Tamil Nadu. The Committee is to supervise the expeditious disposal of the claims and issue necessary directions for this, scrutinize the orders on the claims passed by the authorities under the FRA and submit a report to the court within another two months, by July 2026.

The Forest Rights Act, 2006

FRA, acclaimed as a flagship law on democracy in India and across the world, was the result of nationwide mobilisation during 2002 till 2008 when its Rules were finally notified. FRA unequivocally states in its preamble that ‘forest rights on ancestral lands and their habitat were not adequately recognised in the consolidation of State forests during the colonial period as well as in independent India resulting in historical injustice to the forest dwelling Scheduled Tribes and other traditional forest dwellers who are integral to the very survival and sustainability of the forest ecosystem’. Besides various community rights to access and use forest land, FRA provides for individual rights ‘to hold and live in the forest land under the individual or common occupation for habitation or for self-cultivation’ up to an extent of 4 ha per claimant. And that too only if the claimant ‘had occupied forest land before the 13th day of December, 2005’.

Around 275-300 million people in over 1,70,000 forest fringe villages were dependent upon the forest for livelihood according to the Environment Ministry’s Forestry Outlook Report of 2009. Nearly 400 million depend on non-wood forest produce. The Forest Survey of India puts the figures at 2,05,256 forest fringe villages. In addition, there are thousands of villages wholly located within the forests.

FRA, at long last, decolonises and democratises the colonial rights-negating oppressive forest regime and the exclusionary fortress conservation regime that was built on it. It recognises the customary and traditional forest rights that requires protection and conservation for them to be enjoyed over which the forest dwellers have a long history of battles since colonial times and later when forests were made into an internal colony by law. In 2009, the Environment Ministry conceded that ‘The Schedule Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 assigned rights to protect around 40 million hectares of community forest resources to village level democratic institutions. The fine tuning of other forest-related legislations is needed with respect to the said Act.’ None of these have taken place till date, almost a generation later.

Only forest residents eligible

The Court struck a body blow to FRA when it ordered early this month that those ‘residing outside the forest boundary’ and those ‘who cultivate while having only temporary residence in the forest area’ are not eligible to claim rights. Only those ‘persons permanently residing in the forest area and cultivating’ are eligible. This is sending shock waves across the forest regions of the country still trying to comprehend what it would imply.

But FRA applies to all those who depend on forests, whether residing on forest land or not. The Tribal Affairs Ministry had categorically affirmed in consultation with the Ministry of Law and Justice as early as 9 June 2008 that those ’who are not necessarily residing inside the forest but are depending on the forest for their bona fide livelihood needs would be covered under the definition of forest dwelling scheduled tribes and other traditional forest dwellers’.

If permanent residence is the new criteria, then only 4,526 forest villages with a total population of 22,06,011 of which 13,32,265 belonged to Scheduled Tribes are eligible for individual right to habitation and self-cultivation. As on 31 June 2026, 24,18,197 titles for individual forest rights, both for habitation and self-cultivation, have been issued. Would many lakhs of titles for self-cultivation of those who do not reside on forest land and those who temporarily reside on farm land during seasons, often to evade wildlife attack, be revoked now? 

No commercial crops

Silk cotton is a large, fast-growing fire-resistant deciduous tree that acts as a vital ‘jungle giant’ and micro-ecosystem that supports biodiversity, soil protection and balances local environments. In most parts of the country, it is listed under ‘minor forest produce’. Promoted in the Meghamalai region for ecological reasons as far back under the Working Plan for the forests of the Madura Division (1936-37 to 1945-46) and as recent as the 2014-2024 Working Plan of the Theni Division, it was to ensure that the hill areas are under tree cover. And anyway, the seed pods are what are collected as minor forest produce.

Citing the prevalence of cultivation of silk cotton on forest lands in 3,638 ha in Meghamalai, the Court declared that ‘if commercial crops are permitted and allowed to be cultivated in the forest areas, the very nature of the forest is bound to change. Cultivation of a commercial crop inside the forest areas is completely impermissible as no such right is recognised under FRA, 2006.’ Contrary to this, the FRA actually defines ‘bona fide livelihood needs’ to mean not only fulfilment of livelihood needs of self and family specified in sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Act and includes sale of surplus produce arising out of exercise of such rights’ self-cultivation included.

If this be the new interpretation of the law, what then happens to the commercial crops cultivated through plantation forestry and on leased forest areas of the forest departments by the Forest Development Corporations, and various other government agencies? Timber lots, pulpwood, rubber, cashew, tea, coffee, bamboo, medicinal plants, spices etc cover lakhs of hectares of forest land. Would the forests and afforestation within now being ramped up for huge global investments to generate carbon credits for the global market from carbon sequestration to mitigate global climate change be shelved?

What happens now? Would silk cotton be exterminated from the forests or would it now be harvested by the Forest Department? Or is it that, commercial crops are now permissible to be carried out only by the government agencies and not forest dwellers?

The much-trumpeted PM JGUA programme with a 5-year outlay of ₹79,156 crore (2024–25 to 2028–29) include ₹2,500 Crore Sustainable Agriculture for Forest Rights Act (FRA) Patta Holders that promotes agroforestry also, and another ₹50 Crore Poshan Vatikas (Medicinal & Nutritional Gardens) for the cultivation of medicinal plants, herbs, and nutrient-rich crops etc. Will these now be recast dumping these commercial crops?

It is worthwhile to remember that forests are also the homes to numerous wildlife, small and big. This is part of the forest dwellers ecosystem. With declining forests and food, they are increasingly marauding their habitations for food. Wildlife attacks resulting in loss of lives of tens of thousands of mainly forest dwellers and huge crop loss have become a major issue of concern. The SC had, in November last year, wanted it to be considered for notification as a ‘natural disaster’ under the Disaster Management Act, 2005.

The case

The present court order, a judicial overreach that is rewriting parts of FRA in fundamental ways, emanated from yet another case on the rights of estate workers of Manjolai estate in Tirunelveli District. The estate on forest land leased to a private company since 1929 found itself to be inside the Critical Tiger Habitat of Kalakkad Mundanthurai Tiger Reserve when the Tiger Reserve was legally notified in 2007. With the lease period getting over in 2028, the estate being wound up, the issue then was whether some of these estate workers residing on the estate which is forest land would be eligible for forest rights. Since the estate workers have to leave and start life afresh, should there not be a special rehabilitation package for them?

These were litigated in the Madras High Court which accepted the government’s position that these estate workers and not forest dwellers (though some of them could very well be by law tracing their genealogy from 1929 when the estate was established), and so not coming under the purview of FRA.
Further, they are workers of a private company and the government is not obliged to provide rehabilitation package. It is for the company to compensate them. However, the government will sympathetically consider the extension of government welfare schemes if they are eligible. The Court accepted the government’s stance. These were subsequently challenged in the SC which accepted the Madras High court orders and dismissed the challenges to the Madras High Court orders.

While doing so, the SC took up the issue of forest and wildlife concerns. It directed the CEC in March 2025 to conduct an extensive survey of the entire Agasthyamalai landscape and report within three months on non-forestry activities in these areas that are in violation of the Forest Conservation Act, 1980 (FCA) and the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972. The CEC was to recommend restoration of the forests and Protected Areas within Agasthyamalai landscape. Based on inputs from the Forest Departments and field visits besides relying on the eviction order of an earlier case in the Madras High Court pertaining to Meghamalai, submitted two reports in July 2025 and January 2026.

The State government, through its Forest Department, provided untenable data on the extent of encroachment and list of encroachers inconsistent with applicable law which is FRA. The extent and area of encroachment can only be ascertained after the completion of FRA implementation in the region. They claimed that 4,595 individuals encroached 5,071.27 ha in Srivilliputhur-Megamalai Tiger Reserve, 10.16 hectares by 99 families in Kalakad- Mundanthurai Tiger Reserve and 427.404 ha by 553 persons in Kanyakumari Forest Division besides others.

Based on the findings and recommendations of the CEC, unquestioningly the SC directed a time-bound eviction plan on 29th May 2026 along with rehabilitation where applicable, legal action against wilful violators, and post-eviction ecological restoration, imposed additional penalties against 118 government servants found to be encroachers, and ordered dismantling of all structures, utilities, logistical facilities etc within encroached forest areas. The Court directed the CEC to recommend deployment of paramilitary forces if the State Government failed to comply with the court’s orders.

But the FRA prohibits evicting people ‘till the recognition and verification procedure is complete’. Violation of the provisions of FRA is an offence under FRA for which the Gram Sabha is to issue sixty-day notice to the Chief Secretary headed State Level Monitoring Committee to proceed against the officials who violate the law. Only if no action is forthcoming can the court be approached. In addition, such violations are also an atrocity under the SC/ST Prevention of Atrocities Act, 1989 since 2016 if the victim is an ST or SC.

The eviction order of the SC evoked huge and sustained protests with people maintaining that they have rights under FRA demanding its implementation. Under public pressure and scrutiny, the State Government, and the Department of Revenue and Department of Social Justice then finally appraised the court on FRA and the need to apply FRA on all alleged forest encroachments so that right holders under the law could get their claims verified and recognised. The present November order followed from this.

History repeats?

Important here to recall that the Supreme Court had only asked the States on 18th February 2002 to report back on ‘what steps have been taken to clear the encroachments from the forest’ in IAs No. 703 and 502 in W.P. (C) No. 202 of 1995. The Environment Ministry instead responded with an eviction order in May 2002 to evict encroachers by September of that year. The States, its bureaucracy, especially the forest and police force, unleashed a reign of terror in the forests. This actually triggered a nationwide movement of forest peoples, that got negotiated into a law, the FRA in 2006. The Environment Ministry then had proudly reported in the Lok Sabha on 16th September 2004 that evictions were carried out from 1,52,400.110 ha of forest land between May 2002 and March 2004.

The Ministry soon had to concede in the SC on 21st July 2004 that there has been a ‘historical injustice’ due to the government’s failure to recognise the traditional rights of the forest dwellers which ‘must be finally rectified’.

This time around the SC has gone much ahead, actually ordering eviction and that too even before checking whether this historical injustice is addressed. In many regions the FRA implementation has been flawed, inadequate and incomplete, and just initiated and yet to be initiated across many other parts of the forests as officially acknowledged by the government.

The government failures and injustices this time around was sought to be legally and administratively addressed by the statutory transfer of the primary authority to determine eligibility of the claimants, the rights and extent of forest land to the habitation level Gram Sabha under FRA. The onus of initiating, verifying, determining and deciding on all these is with the Gram Sabha. Where bureaucratic resistance has been addressed by the Gram Sabhas, rights recognition has progressed, for the first time since independence.

Will this November SC order trigger another wave of illegal evictions across the country to perpetuate the historic injustice when FRA prohibits eviction ‘till the recognition and verification procedure is complete’?

(Author: C.R. Bijoy examines natural resource conflicts and governance issues)

References