India is the lighthouse of having the world’s largest cooperative network, with 8.37 lakh registered societies and more than 31 crore members as of March 2025 [12]. Yet, a simple question remains: if cooperatives reach so many people, why do many farmers still struggle to secure fair prices, access markets, and earn better incomes? We can get the answer if we look at the difference between the presence of cooperatives and their effectiveness. We have seen some cooperatives, such as Amul and IFFCO, build strong market networks; others are fraught with numerous problems of weak management, inadequate resources, and poor member participation. This dichotomous nature of cooperatives led us to think beyond the increasing number of cooperatives, but to make existing ones more effective.
Farmer and Agricultural Landscape
Indian agriculture has made substantial gains in production, diversification, and market connectivity, but the central economic problem for many farmers is increasingly what happens post-harvest of crops. The literature demonstrates that small and marginal farmers mainly face huge challenges, including weak marketable surpluses, weak bargaining power, inadequate storage and processing, asymmetric market information, and high transaction costs, jeopardizing their lives and livelihoods, precarious economic condition. The recent economic survey 2025–26 corroborated that small landholdings, climate risks, productivity gaps, and weak market integration continue to weigh on farm incomes [1].
Relevance of Cooperatives and FPOs
To address these problems, cooperatives and farmer-producer organizations play essential roles through expanding access to collective bargaining, value chains, and markets [1].
Their economic value is not simply that farmers meet under one institutional roof. It lies in aggregation: many small producers can collectively procure inputs, store produce, negotiate with buyers, undertake processing, build brands, and reach markets that may be difficult to access individually. In that sense, a well-run cooperative can function as market infrastructure for its members.
The point is especially visible in commodities such as onion. Onion prices are seasonal and sensitive to weather, arrivals, storage conditions, exports, and policy decisions. When supplies are abundant, producers face weak prices; when supplies tighten, consumers face sudden increases. The policy challenge is therefore two-sided: farmers need remunerative returns while consumers need affordable food. Cooperative institutions can help bridge that gap, although they cannot substitute for efficient markets or good governance.
From collective selling to collective market power
The economic logic of cooperation is straightforward. Individually, a small farmer may have little influence over the timing, volume or terms of a sale. Collectively, farmers can create a larger and more reliable supply, reduce repeated transactions, share storage and logistics, and invest in grading, packaging and processing. The result can be lower transaction costs and a stronger negotiating position. Research on Indian agricultural value chains has repeatedly highlighted the importance of collective institutions and better vertical coordination in improving smallholder participation in markets [2,3].
This does not mean that cooperatives automatically guarantee higher prices. Their performance depends on procurement practices, professional management, transparency, member participation, and access to finance. Evidence from smallholder dairy systems, for example, shows that cooperative participation can improve household welfare when the institution provides dependable market access and effective services [4]. The lesson is important: the cooperative model works when collective ownership is matched by commercial discipline.
Role of NAFED in Onion Market
Onion provides one of the clearest illustrations of the cooperative role in price stabilisation. The National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India (NAFED), an apex cooperative marketing federation, has been one of the government’s principal agencies for procurement and disposal of onion buffer stocks under the Price Stabilisation Fund. The mechanism works in two directions: onions are procured from farmers when the buffer is built, stored for later use, and released into markets when prices or availability warrant intervention [5].
We have witnessed a particularly visible intervention by NAFED in September 2024. During this time, the Government launched retail sales of buffer onion at ₹35 per kg through mobile vans and outlets of NCCF and NAFED in major consumption centres, initially Delhi and Mumbai, and then expanded the programme to other cities. The Department of Consumer Affairs reported that by 13 September, Mumbai’s retail onion price had fallen from ₹61 to ₹56 per kg, while the subsidised cooperative-channel sale continued at ₹35 per kg [6].
The intervention was not merely a retail subsidy story. It linked procurement, storage, transport and retail distribution. In October 2024, for example, 840 tonnes of NAFED-procured onion reached to Delhi from Nashik; most was released through Azadpur Mandi to augment market supply, while part of the stock was earmarked for retail sale at ₹35 per kg [7]. This is a useful example of how a cooperative agency can operate between production regions and consumption centres rather than leaving the market to adjust only through retail prices.
The approach has continued to evolve. In 2026, the government again used NAFED and NCCF to release buffer onion at ₹35 per kg, with supplies moved through road transport and the Kanda Express rail system. By 1 September 2026, the government reported retail sales through cooperative outlets and mobile vans and expansion of buffer disposal to 19 cities [8]. On 26 August 2026, the all-India average monthly retail price of onion was reported at ₹37.87 per kg, against the intervention price of ₹35 per kg [9].
For consumers, the significance is immediate: a cooperative distribution channel can make an essential commodity available below the prevailing market price during a price spike. For farmers, the other side of the mechanism is equally important. In 2024, the government reported that NAFED and NCCF procured 4.7 lakh tonnes of onion for the price-stabilisation buffer, with procurement payments made directly to farmers. The reported average buffer procurement price was ₹2,833 per quintal, compared with ₹1,724 per quintal in the previous year [10]. Thus, the intervention attempted to balance two objectives that are often treated as conflicting: remunerative procurement for farmers and affordable availability for consumers.
This is also a reminder that a cooperative’s contribution to welfare cannot be measured only by the price paid to a farmer or the price charged to a consumer. The broader question is whether the institution reduces avoidable market costs, improves the timing and reliability of supply, reduces extreme price movements, and allows producers to retain a stronger position in the value chain.
The new policy push
The policy environment has changed significantly since the establishment of the Ministry of Cooperation in July 2021. The government’s recent agenda seeks to expand cooperatives beyond traditional credit functions into storage, processing, services, dairy, fisheries, seeds, organics and exports. The National Cooperation Policy 2025 sets out a ten-year roadmap built around six strategic pillars, 16 objectives and 83 recommendations [12].
One of the most consequential reforms is the transformation of Primary Agricultural Credit Societies (PACS) into multipurpose local institutions. The Economic Survey 2025–26 reports that 67,930 PACS are being computerised; 54,150 had been brought onto the ERP platform, and 43,658 were live. By March 2025, 18,183 new multipurpose cooperative societies had been registered [1]. The model bye-laws also allow PACS to undertake activities such as input supply, storage, processing and other services rather than remaining narrowly focused on credit. These initiatives indicate an attempt to move cooperatives from being local service organisations to participants in national and international value chains.
Challenges faced by Cooperatives
The cooperative story should not be romanticised. India’s cooperative institutions have also faced problems of political interference, weak governance, limited professional management, inadequate capital and poor member participation. Reviews of the sector have identified these constraints as major reasons why some cooperatives fail to translate collective ownership into sustained economic benefits [14]. A cooperative can be democratically owned and still be commercially weak.
The next phase therefore requires a different standard of performance. Cooperatives should be judged not only by the number of members or societies registered, but by measurable outcomes: procurement volumes, payment timeliness, storage utilisation, processing capacity, wastage reduction, member price realisation, access to markets, consumer affordability and the share of value that returns to producers. Digital systems can improve transparency, but technology cannot replace accountable governance.
There is also a need to distinguish cooperative action from government control. Public intervention may be necessary for food security and price stabilisation, particularly in essential commodities such as onion. But durable cooperative enterprises need member ownership, commercial autonomy, professional managers and competitive market discipline. Government policy is most useful when it builds this capacity rather than permanently replacing it.
Farmers as market actors
The future of Indian agriculture will depend not only on producing more, but on who controls aggregation, storage, processing, information, logistics, branding and access to buyers. In fragmented markets, these functions can determine how much of the consumer’s rupee reaches the producer.
Cooperatives cannot solve every agricultural problem. They cannot eliminate climate risk, guarantee prices in every season or remove all intermediaries. What they can do is change the bargaining position of farmers. A group of producers with pooled volumes, storage, market information, processing capacity and a credible buyer network enters the market differently from an individual producer selling a small surplus under time pressure. The onion market is one of the best examples of that.
Concluding Remarks
India’s cooperative movement is entering a new phase. The challenge is to convert a large institutional footprint into stronger economic participation for members. The most successful cooperatives will be those that combine democratic ownership with professional management, digital systems, reliable infrastructure and access to high-value markets.
From NAFED’s onion interventions to the proposed transformation of PACS into multipurpose rural institutions, the central idea is the same: collective organisation can give small producers greater scale and a stronger position in the market. For consumers, it can also create more reliable and affordable access to essential commodities. The real measure of the cooperative movement, therefore, is not how many institutions exist, but whether those institutions help farmers capture more value while keeping markets efficient and consumers protected. However, NAFED’s intervention in the onion sector needs to be strengthened by engaging more FPOs to ensure that small and marginal onion farmers have timely access to real-time market price information and better market opportunities. Despite the challenges they face, cooperatives can play a critical role in bridging the gap between producers and markets.
(Author: Dr Rahul Thombare | Md Sahidul Islam, Research Officers, Vaikunth Mehta National Institute of Cooperative Management (VAMNICOM), Pune)
References
[1] Government of India, Economic Survey 2025–26: Agriculture and Food Management, Ministry of Finance, Government of India, 2026.
[2] Pratap Singh Birthal, P. K. Joshi and Ashok Gulati, “Vertical coordination in high-value commodities: Implications for smallholders,” MTID Discussion Paper No. 85, International Food Policy Research Institute, April 2005.
[3] P. S. Birthal, D. S. Negi and D. Roy, “Impact of traditional versus modern dairy value chains on food security: Evidence from India’s dairy sector,” Food Policy, Vol. 83, 2019, pp. 260–270.
[4] A. Kumar, S. Saroj, P. K. Joshi and H. Takeshima, “Does cooperative membership improve household welfare? Evidence from a panel data analysis of smallholder dairy farmers in Bihar, India,” Food Policy, Vol. 75, 2018, pp. 24–36.
[5] National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India Ltd. (NAFED), Annual Report 2024–25, NAFED, New Delhi, 2025.
[6] Press Information Bureau, Government of India, “Centre’s initiative of retail selling of Onion at subsidised rate reflecting decline in price,” Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, September 14, 2024.
[7] Press Information Bureau, Government of India, “Second train with 840 metric tonnes of onion arrives in Delhi,” Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, October 30, 2024.
[8] Press Information Bureau, Government of India, “Adequate Onion Availability: Government expands calibrated and targeted release of buffer stocks through Kanda Express and road transport,” September 1, 2026.
[9] DD India, “Centre begins targeted release of onion buffer stocks to check seasonal price rise,” August 26, 2026.
[10] Press Information Bureau, Government of India, “Food and Consumer Affairs Minister Shri Pralhad Joshi flags off mobile vans selling onion at Rs 35 per kg,” September 5, 2024.
[11] Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd. (GCMMF), “Chairman Speech – 51st Annual General Body Meeting,” 2025.
[12] Ministry of Cooperation, Government of India, National Cooperation Policy 2025, July 2025.
[13] National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), Special Module on Cooperatives in India: International Year of Cooperatives 2025, June 2025.
[14] Alok K. Sahoo, Sanat K. Meher, Tarak C. Panda, Susrita Sahu, Rukeiya Begum and N. C. Barik, “Critical Review on Cooperative Societies in Agricultural Development in India,” Current Journal of Applied Science and Technology, Vol. 39, No. 22, 2020, pp. 114–121.
Mainstream Weekly