Home > 2026 > War Is Subjected To Democratic Accountability : Most Salutory Outcome of (…)

Mainstream, Vol 64 No 27, November 16, 2026

War Is Subjected To Democratic Accountability : Most Salutory Outcome of Mid-Term Results | Vijay Kumar

Monday 16 November 2026, by Vijay Kumar

The single greatest outcome of the bluenamy (blue wave) in favour of Democrats in the Mid-Term election is that War on Iran entailed heavy political cost for Trump and the Republican Party. This is not surprising. The greatest surprise in history of democracy is the defeat of Winston Churchill after the Second World War. He won the war, defeated Hitler and Fascism, saved democracy and western supremacy and went down in history as one of the greatest statesmen of the twentieth century, and yet, the election, held immediately after end of second World War, he lost to Clement Atlee, because six years of prolonged war inflicted immense economic afflictions on people of England. When election was held, the pride of victory was subordinated to economic anxiety. Similarly, Vietnam War made President Lyndon Johnson so unpopular that he had no courage to go for the second-term, and that made easy for Richard Nixon to occupy White House. Again, senior Bush won Iraq war in 1991, but lost to Bill Clinton in 1992, when Clinton made ‘economic stupid’ as central plank of his electoral campaign. The results have brought to the fore crucial difference in democracy and authoritarian regime. Trump has been forced to account for in democratic America, whereas authoritarian Putin escaped any scrutiny in iron-curtain Russia.

The Iran war disrupted the supply of energy, oil and natural gas and gravely affected the world economy. Just as English people demonstrated political maturity by giving premium to economic hardships rather than chest-thumping celebration of victory in war, American voters, too, displayed political sagacity and adulthood and voted decisively against Trump and the Republican Party.

It is true that the results in Mid-Term have generally gone against incumbent President’s Party, but scale and sweep are mind-bogglingly staggering.

It is the economic travails, caused by Iran war, that is, the single decisive factor in turning the tide in favour of Democrats. The final result was literally tsunami. Not one – but in seven red States - results were flipped in favour of Democrats. Texas and Kansas, the two strongest bastions of the Republican voted in favour of Democrats. The only red State which bucked the trend was the third largest State, Florida – perhaps, because it is the home State of Trump. The sweeping tide against Trump and the Republican Party is further underscored by two results----the first is the defeat of Susan Collins in Main, who was Senator for more than 30 years. She was moderate Republican, who often sided with Democrats, but the blue wave against Trump and the Republican Party engulfed even Susan Collins. Though this is a great loss for the Senate, as she was the liberal and progressive voice, but her defeat offers barometer for reading voters’ angst. The second result pertains to resounding victory of Abdul EI Sayed, an Egyptian Muslim, who defeated Republican, Mike Roger, despite section of Democrats was against him. Sayed would be the first Muslim Senator.

Since Democrats have captured both Senate and House of Representative, their first task should be to retrieve the power of the Congress. Under the American Constitution, the Congress, as a legislative wing, is most important and powerful political institution, and it must exercise democratic oversight over presidential action. As Trump has expanded the breadth of executive power, it is incumbent upon Democrats-controlled Congress to interrogate and curtail it. The imperial presidency was never contemplated in the Constitution.

Having seized both Senate and House of Representatives and thereby rendered Trump lame duck President, Democrats must restrain their impulses and should not rush ahead with impeachment of Trump. Instead, they should go ahead with impeachment of Defence Secretary, Pete Hegseth and Attorney General, Tod Blanch, who has debilitated the credibility and independence of Justice Department.

Yet another significant outcome is that the issue of economic hardship has succeeded in diluting and neutralizing MAGA. MAGA was nothing but a white supremacism of most horrendous nature. The Mid- Term Results have demonstrated that identity politics, rooted in noxious combination of race, religion and capitalism, can be countered by raising economic issues which are central to lives of the common people. It is this outcome which should be emulated in other parts of the world, including India.

The Mid-Term results in the wake of dramatic resurgence of Lula in the second round after losing the first round in Brazil, defeat of Victor Orban, brazen-facedly rightist, in Hungary and election results in Serbia have shown that left and liberal forces are capable of giving pushback to far-right agenda, grounded in ethno-nationalism. The most emancipatory outcome of the Mid-Term results is that it has infused hope in left and liberals that rightist ideology, anchored in hideous mixture of religion/race and neo-liberal forces, can be countered. Technically, Trump was not on the Ballot, and yet, result is referendum on his presidency. The celebration by Democrats must be tampered with reality.It is a moment of triumph for Democrats, but the question is can they maintain the momentum till 2028 November when Presidential election would be held in absence of any charismatic leader like Bill Clinton and Obama. Trump is humbled, but the trumpism, as toxic phenomenon, would survive, just as MacCarthism survived even after the death of Joseph MacCarthy and Thatecherism after the defeat of Margaret Thatcher.

(Author: Vijay Kumar, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India; author of the book The Theory of Basic Structure : Saviour of The Constitution and Democracy )