Home > Archives (2006 on) > 2015 > Praful Bidwai is No More: Rest in Peace, Comrade

Mainstream, VOL LIII No 28 New Delhi July 4, 2015

Praful Bidwai is No More: Rest in Peace, Comrade

Monday 6 July 2015


Praful Bidwai is no more. He died in Amsterdam on Tuesday evening (June 23, 2015) due to a cardiac arrest,

With his death we have lost the ‘best Left-wing journalist’ in this part of South Asia whose articles appeared in many newspapers and magazines in the subcontinent and in the Middle East and was frequently published by The Guardian,Le Monde Diplomatique as well.

Praful will be missed by thousands and thousands of his readers (this pen-pusher included) who were ‘groomed’ by him in a career spanning more than four decades. For them he was one such voice who remained uncompromising in his strident criticism of communal fundamentalisms of various kinds and the crony capitalism which is having a field day these days. He was a leading voice for nuclear disarmament and peace as well and had written extensively on the subject.

It was a strange coincidence that we met last in the Capital when a memorial meeting was organised by Communist Party of India to remember the legendary Comrade Govind Pansare who was assassinated a few days earlier (February 20, 2015 to be premise). He was to speak in the meeting. The meeting was yet to start and I could steal some time to talk to him. He told he was working on a book—which was near completion—on the Left movement in the country and had interviewed many activists associated with the movement to listen to their understanding of challenges before the Left. And in that connection he had long meeting with Com Pansare—once in Kolhapur and once possibly in Mumbai. He shared his fascination of the energy Pansare still had at that age for ‘the cause’.

A few days after the meeting, there was a call from him asking for a phone number of a Dalit activist Incidentally I did not have the number. Yes, that was the last time I spoke to him.

Many details of his life have found mention in his obituary references, but none mentions about the days of his youth when he happened to be studying at IIT Mumbai and was one of the founders of a left group called ‘Magowa’ (Pursuit) which came up in the early seventies. Dr Anant Phadke, a leading health activist and a left wing thinker associated with ‘Shramik Mukti Dal’—who was also part of Magowa then—said Praful along with Sudhir Bedekar was the ‘mentor’ of the group and there was a time when they had eleven whole timers. Praful left his studies in between, and joined the struggle of Adivasis which was taking place at Shahada (Districe Dhule, Maharashtra) as a whole timer and worked with them for around two years. And Praful was not alone from the group who had taken the plunge. There was Kumar Shiralkar and many others.

If Naxalbari had mesmerised the Indian young radicals in those days on a larger scale, the struggle at Shahada (albeit on a small scale) had similarly mesmerised the Marathi youth then. One still remembers visiting to meet Amber Singh, a leader of the struggle hailing from the tribal community itself, when he was undergoing treatment at a hospital in Pune. He died a few months later.

Perhaps because of health reasons Praful could not continue working with the tribals and had to return to Pune. Here he took the initiative in forming the ‘Workers Democratic Union’ to work with the working masses in the city and adjoining areas. It continued for a few years.

Later he left organised Left politics and switched to journalism but continued to raise his voice for a just, equitable and inclusive society in India and peace and nuclear disarma-ment globally. Although he did not join any of the mainstream Left parties thereafter and had perhaps a few criticisms to offer about their functioning but he always remained a friend of the Left politics. I think that was the concern which prompted him to undertake the volumi-nous work, The Phoenix Moment: Challenges Confronting the Indian Left (Harper Collins), which is being described as ‘an epic study of the achievements and crises facing the Indian Left’. which I hope would be published soon.

Rest in Peace, Comrade.

(Courtesy: Countercurrents.org)

Subhash Gatade is the author of Pahad Se Uncha Aadmi (2010), Godse’s Children: Hindutva Terror in India, (2011) and The Saffron Condition: The Politics of Repression and Exclusion in Neoliberal India (2011). He is also the Convener of the New Socialist Initiative (NSI). He can be contacted at e-mail: subhash.gatade-[at]gmail.com

ISSN : 0542-1462 / RNI No. : 7064/62